Evaluation of Surgical Strategies for Bilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis Using Excised Canine Larynges

OBJECTIVE:The objective of this study was to provide a theoretical basis for the selection of optimal surgical procedures in ex vivo simulated bilateral vocal fold paralysis (BVFP). STUDY DESIGN:Four surgical stages were sequentially performed on 10 excised canine larynges with simulated BVFP: (1) transverse cordotomy, (2) medial arytenoidectomy, (3) subtotal arytenoidectomy, and (4) total arytenoidectomy. MATERIALS AND METHODS:The sound pressure level, the signal-to-noise ratio, the glottal resistance, the glottal airflow (GF), the maximal glottal area (MGA), and spectrograms were measured after each stage. For comparative analysis of variance, a randomized block design and the Student-Newman-Keuls test were performed. RESULTS:Under stable phonation, the sound pressure level showed no significant differences among the four stages. The signal-to-noise ratio was significantly different between the preoperative period and stage 1, as well as between stages 2 and 3. Glottal resistance was significantly different between the preoperative period and stage 1 and between stages 1 and 2. GF and MGA were significantly different among all stages, compared with those between stages 3 and 4 for GF and the preoperative period and stage 1 for MGA. The spectrograms indicated that the degree of disorder in the acoustic signals gradually increased. CONCLUSIONS:Based on a comprehensive analysis of GF and voice quality in excised canine larynges, which simulated BVFP, our results suggest that the optimal surgical choice for BVFP is either medial or subtotal arytenoidectomy.