The Logic Of Physical Garbage Collection In Deduplicating Storage

Most storage systems that write in a log-structured manner need a mechanism for garbage collection (GC), reclaiming and consolidating space by identifying unused areas on disk. In a deduplicating storage system, GC is complicated by the possibility of numerous references to the same underlying data. We describe two variants of garbage collection in a commercial deduplicating storage system, a logical GC that operates on the files containing deduplicated data and a physical GC that performs sequential I/O on the underlying data. The need for the second approach arises from a shift in the underlying workloads, in which exceptionally high duplication ratios or the existence of millions of individual small files result in unacceptably slow GC using the file-level approach. Under such workloads, determining the liveness of chunks becomes a slow phase of logical GC. We find that physical GC decreases the execution time of this phase by up to two orders of magnitude in the case of extreme workloads and improves it by approximately 10-60% in the common case, but only after additional optimizations to compensate for its higher initialization overheads.