14 What RNA world ?? Ancestral polypeptides likely participated in the origins of translation

A widespread consensus holds that protein synthesis according to a genetic code was launched entirely by sophisticated RNA molecules that played both coding and functional roles. This belief persists, unsupported by phylogenetic evidence for ancestral ribozymes that catalyzed either amino acid activation or tRNA aminoacylation. By contrast, we have adduced strong experimental evidence that the most highly conserved portions of contemporary aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS) accelerate both reactions well in excess of rates achieved by RNA aptomers derived from combinatorial libraries and of rates required for primordial protein synthesis. Such ancestral enzymes, or “Urzymes”, characterized for Class I (TrpRS (Pham et al., 2010, 2007) and LeuRS (Collier et al., 2013); 130 residues) and Class II (HisRS; 120–140 residues; (Li et al., 2011)) synthetases generally have promiscuous amino acid specificities, whereas ATP and cognate tRNA affinities are within an order of magnitude of those for contemporary enzymes...