Classifying tropical deciduous vegetation: a comparison of multiple approaches in Popa Mountain Park, Myanmar

Although several studies have reported that rule-based methods are better than other image classification methods, no study has quantified their performance for tropical deciduous vegetation classification. We compared rule-based and maximum likelihood classification MLC approaches in classifying tropical deciduous vegetation in Popa Mountain Park, Myanmar. Classification was primarily based on Thematic Mapper TM bands of multi-season Landsat images, normalized difference vegetation indices NDVIs, NDVI differences, mean NDVI and elevation advanced spaceborne thermal emission and reflection radiometer digital elevation model Aster DEM. We used two main approaches for classification, a single-step approach in which all vegetation types were classified in one procedure, and a two-step approach in which forest and non-forest were discriminated first and then forest was classified into additional classes. Each of those approaches was conducted with and without elevation under the rule-based and MLC approaches, yielding eight separate methods. The two-step approaches generated more accurate results and all classifications improved markedly when elevation was included. The rule-based two-step with elevation approach produced the best overall accuracy and reliability.