Comparison of treatment outcomes between involved-field and elective nodal irradiation in limited-stage small cell lung cancer.

The present study was performed to assess the usefulness of involved-field irradiation and the impact of F-18-fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography-based staging on treatment outcomes in limited-stage small cell lung cancer. Eighty patients who received definitive chemoradiotherapy for limited-stage small cell lung cancer were retrospectively analyzed. Fifty patients were treated with involved-field irradiation, which means that the radiotherapy portal includes only clinically identifiable tumors. The other 30 patients were irradiated with a comprehensive portal, including uninvolved mediastinal and/or supraclavicular lymph nodes, so-called elective nodal irradiation. No significant difference was seen in clinical factors between the two groups. At a median follow-up of 27 months (range, 575 months), no significant differences were observed in 3 year overall survival (44.6 vs. 54.1, P 0.220) and 3 year progression-free survival (24.4 vs. 42.8, P 0.133) between the involved-field irradiation group and the elective nodal irradiation group, respectively. For patients who did not undergo positron emission tomography scans, 3 year overall survival (29.3 vs. 56.3, P 0.022) and 3 year progression-free survival (11.0 vs. 50.0, P 0.040) were significantly longer in the elective nodal irradiation group. Crude incidences of isolated nodal failure were 6.0 in the involved-field irradiation group and 0 in the elective nodal irradiation group, respectively. All isolated nodal failures were developed in patients who had not undergone positron emission tomography scans in their initial work-ups. If patients did not undergo positron emission tomography-based staging, the omission of elective nodal irradiation resulted in impaired survival outcomes and raised the risk of isolated nodal failure. Therefore, involved-field irradiation for limited-stage small cell lung cancer might be reasonable only with positron emission tomography scan implementation.