[Access to brain death diagnostics].

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES:In Germany the diagnosis of brain death must strictly adhere to the expert guidelines of the German chamber of physicians. For patients with primary supratentorial or hypoxic brain injury aged 2 years or more, repeat clinical examinations or one complete examination combined with an ancillary test are equally accurate. This study aimed to identify factors with potential impact on whether and by which means a formal brain death examination is pursued. MATERIAL AND METHODS:A retrospective analysis was carried out of recorded data of all patients who died in the acute phase after severe brain injury during mechanical ventilation in an intensive care unit and who were registered at the north east regional bureau of the German organ procurement organization (Deutsche Stiftung Organtransplantation) between 2001 and 2010. RESULTS:Of 5988 reported patients, a protocol-specified brain death examination was initiated in 3023, leading to a diagnosis of brain death in 2592. All other patients died due to permanent cardiac arrest. Patients were less likely to undergo brain death examinations in the presence of one or more of the following characteristics: perceived medical contraindication for organ donation, patient age greater than 69 years, hypoxic brain damage, treatment in a hospital without neurological and neurosurgical departments and death on a weekend or public holiday. In 2192 patients (72.5%), neurologists or neurosurgeons participated in the diagnostic procedures and in 926 of these cases members of specialized external diagnostic expert teams were involved. Ancillary tests were rarely used by physicians based at the treating hospitals (31.1%) but on a regular basis by members of the external teams (93.4%). The risk of death due to permanent cardiac arrest before completion of the brain death examination was increased approximately 7-fold when a neurological or neurosurgical consultation with ancillary studies was not performed. DISCUSSION:Access to neurological expertise and to ancillary tests has a significant impact on the provision of guideline-specified diagnostic procedures for suspected brain death. Centralized diagnostic teams offer an effective means to support qualified brain death examinations.