Formulas for the quantitation of intrathecal IgG production: Their validity in the presence of blood-brain barrier damage and their utility in multiple sclerosis

There are several formulas for the quantitative determination of intrathecal IgG production: Reiber and Felgenhauer's formula (IgG(loc)), the Extended IgG index, Tourtellotte's formula (TOURT), Schuller and Sagar's formula (SCHULL), the IgG index, the Log IgG index, and Blennow and co-workers' formula (IGGPROD). To evaluate the utility of these formulas in the presence of blood-brain barrier (BBB) damage, we present the results from a study of serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) samples from 125 healthy individuals, 18–88 years of age; 1072 consecutive patients without oligoclonal IgG bands (OCBs) in the CSF, 683 without BBB damage (CSF/S: albumin ratio < 9.8) and 389 with BBB damage (CSF/S albumin ratio 9.8–30); and 106 patients with definite multiple sclerosis (MS). The relation between the CSF/S albumin ratio and the CSF/S IgG ratio was remarkably linear in both healthy individuals (r = 0.95; P < 0.0001) and patients without oligoclonal bands in the CSF (r = 0.95; P < 0.0001). Therefore, IgG(loc) and the Extended IgG index, two formulas based on a nonlinear relation between the CSF/S albumin ratio and the CSF/S IgG ratio, yielded biased results (lower values) in the presence of BBB damage. TOURT and SCHULL also yielded biased (higher) values in the presence of BBB damage, probably because of incorrect constants in these formulas. There were no significant correlations between the CSF/S albumin ratio (i.e. the BBB function) and the IgG index or the Log IgG index, two dimensionless quotients for the detection of intrathecal IgG production, or between the CSF/S albumin ratio and IGGPROD, an empirical formula for the determination of intrathecal IgG production in mg/l. These results show that the IgG index, the Log IgG index and IGGPROD all give valid quantitative determinations of intrathecal IgG production even in the presence of BBB damage. The percentage of MS patients with a formula value higher than the mean + 2 SD of the control value was identical for the IgG index, the Log IgG index and IGGPROD (92%), and similar to the number of MS patients exhibiting OCBs in their CSF (96%). These results suggest that the quantitative determination of intrathecal IgG production is almost as sensitive as the qualitative detection of OCBs for demonstration of intrathecal IgG production.