The Severe Short Stature in Two Siblings with a Heterozygous IGF1 Mutation is Not Caused by a Dominant Negative Effect of the Putative Truncated Protein

Objective: While in previous studies heterozygosity for an Insulin-Like Growth Factor 1 (IGF1) defect only modestly decreased height and head circumference, we recently reported on two siblings with severe short stature with a maternally transmitted heterozygous duplication of 4 nucleotides, resulting in a frame shift and a premature termination codon in the IGF1 gene. In this paper we describe the structural and functional characteristics of the putative truncated IGF-I protein.Design: Two children, their mother and maternal grandfather carried the mutation. In addition, two family members who were not affected were included in the study. Mutant (MT) IGF-I was synthesized in oxidized and reduced form using two methods. Neutral gel filtration studies were carried out with wild-type (WT) and synthetic MT IGF-I. Binding analysis of synthetic MT IGF-I to the IGF1R and insulin receptors were performed with EBNA-293 cells, stably transfected with the IGF-I receptor, and IM9 cells. L6 cells were used to examine the mitogenic potency and the potential antagonizing effect of synthetic MT IGF-I by [(3)H]-thymidine incorporation assays.Results: In the sera of both the carriers and non-carriers the proportion of (125)I-IGF-I that was associated with the 150 kDa complex was somewhat less (varying between similar to 37 and similar to 52%) than in normal pooled serum (similar to 53 -similar to 63%) and, instead, slightly increased amounts of radioactivity were eluted in the 40-50 kDa fraction (consisting of binary IGF-IGFBP complexes) or remained unbound. Synthetic MT IGF-I did not bind to the IGF-I receptor, nor antagonize the growth-promoting effect of IGF-I. It did bind to IGFBPs, but was barely incorporated into 150 kDa complexes. Because in all cases WT IGF-I immunoreactivity was recovered in one peak, corresponding to the MW of WT IGF-I, i.e. similar to 7.6 kDa, an interaction of circulating truncated mutant peptide with WT IGF-I is very unlikely.Conclusions: There is no evidence that the severe short stature associated with heterozygosity for this novel IGF1 mutation in children born from a mother with the same mutation is caused by a dominant negative effect of the truncated protein. We speculate that the growth failure is caused by a combination of partial IGF-I deficiency, placental IGF-I insufficiency, and other genetic factors. (C) 2010 Growth Hormone Research Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.