Sampling method affects estimates of population density and reproductive maturity of summer-form pistachio psyllids

In this study, the effects of using three different sampling methods (yellow sticky traps, beating tray, organdy bags) on estimating the distribution through the canopy of the summer-form adults of the pistachio psyllid (Agonoscena targionii (Licht.)) was investigated throughout the vegetative period. The traps or bags were hung at two heights in the tree canopy, 3.5 in above ground and 2 m above ground. Psyllids were counted weekly, and their sex determined. Adult abundance varied during the study, but all three sampling methods indicated that densities were higher in the upper canopy than the lower canopy. The percentage of females having mature eggs was lowest in late May, and highest in June an September. Sex ratios were highly variable among sampling dates and among sampling methods, at both canopy heights. Sex ratios in bags tended to be more female-biased in the lower canopy than in the upper canopy. Sticky trap counts were significantly male biased, more so in the upper canopy than in the lower canopy. Mean sex ratios differed significantly between bag and sticky trap samples at both heights, but did not differ significantly between tray and bag samples at either height. In addition, for a given tray or bag count, sticky trap catch of males was larger than catch of females, and was larger in the upper canopy than in the lower canopy. Bag counts (psyllids per leaflet) strongly increased with tray count. Of the three sampling methods described here, the bag samples provided direct estimates of psyllid numbers per leaflet, but this method is extremely time consuming. Bag counts (psyllids per leaflet) increased with tray count, suggesting that beat trays can be used to estimate absolute densities.